top of page

Plenary Council 2020: Joint Parish Statement

This statement is made by a group of parishes in Melbourne. We are deeply concerned about past trends while also hopeful that real change can be achieved before and at Plenary Council 2020. The extent of the sexual abuse tragedy is overwhelming. We believe that the leadership in the Church has failed ordinary Catholics. We experience a profound feeling of shame and demand change. The Church must reform itself, and protect the rights of people, especially children, rather than of those who have caused this damage. The Church needs the full involvement of women at all levels, and recognition of the role of laity and priests as equal members, with the Bishops, in the People of God.


We want to see the following changes made:

  1. Address the Sexual Abuse Crisis. All Catholic institutions with possible historical sex abuse complaints should immediately join the redress system. A trauma-informed, treatment approach with support that is both competent and adequate is needed to assist the survivors. The Church must provide an on-going ministry of support to victims/survivors of clerical child sexual abuse.

  2. Change the Nature of the Plenary Council. If the Council is not seen as genuinely representative of the Church it will fail. A majority of the delegates to the Council should be lay people and priests working in parishes, with at least half of these women. Voting must be open and transparent, with the ‘sense of the faithful’ revealed by processes involving all those attending.

  3. Encourage an Opening and Inclusive Church. Many are currently excluded from full participation in the life of the Church. These groups include women, the LGBTQI communities and those divorced and re-married. The Council must make a strong commitment to full inclusion of these and other groups.

  4. Promote Servant Leadership for a Humble Church. A new leadership model is needed. This requires dismantling the dominant male celibate club, banishing the trappings of power and reshaping the training of priests. All new priests need regular mentoring and support to help them develop servant leadership.

  5. Change the Composition of the Priesthood. Rather than relying on overseas priests and the clustering of parishes under one priest, immediate action is needed on widening access to the priesthood. We support optional celibacy for priests, re-admitting former priests now married, beginning the ordination of women as deacons and endorsing the principle of women priests.

  6. Implement New Governance Changes. The Council must instigate a move to a new governance structure, suitable for the People of God. Lay men and women should be involved at all levels, with transparent and accountable structures throughout the Church. All leaders should be subject to regular review.

  7. Make the Liturgy More Relevant. The Council should move to make the liturgy more relevant for a truly synodal church, for example by reforming the language used, reinstating the Third Rite of Reconciliation and removing the moral restrictions on attending the sacraments. As Pope Francis has said, the Eucharist is not a prize for the perfect but nourishment for the weak.

  8. Renew our Focus on the Poor and Marginalised. The Council should set out to revitalise and extend the important work for the poor and marginalised that the Australian Church has done over the past 150 years. We need to build on past achievements to increase our outward-facing focus, reaching out to our first nation people, asylum seekers, the vulnerable and the disadvantaged.

  9. Protect and Restore the Earth. The Australian Church has failed to respond adequately to climate change and the destruction of the earth more generally.  We endorse a major new mandate in this area, consistent with the powerful call from Pope Francis in Laudato Si’.

bottom of page